Option 4: Adjust the Cost of Capital

A final option that would, in principle, reflect the cost of equity consequences of operating leases would be to allow rent expenses to flow through income without adjusting either income or net assets but, instead, to adjust the cost of capital for the implied change in capital structure. As management takes on more leases, there is an implied shift between debt and equity in the remaining capital base. Thus, this option would incorporate the cost of equity associated with leases through a changing cost of capital for the whole business. As the business leases more assets, the cost of capital would go up and, conversely, declines in leased assets would reduce the cost of capital.

While this adjustment is theoretically consistent with the economics of leasing, it contains an obvious drawback, i.e., additional complexity in adjusting the cost of capital for subtle changes in target capital structure over time and difficulty in communicating these changes in the cost of capital. Thus, this adjustment is practical only for major changes in leasing policy, such as divestiture of a leasing intensive operation, where the cost of capital effect would be expected to be significant and non-recurring.

© 2015 by Hodak Value Advisors.