Option 2: Capitalize Using Actual Terms

This treatment capitalizes operating leases at the pre-tax cost of debt based on the actual terms of the lease. The capitalized value is updated each year to reflect both the passing of time and any changes in lease terms (i.e., rent escalators).

The mechanics of this adjustment affect income differently than treatment as a capitalized lease; instead of calculating the depreciation expense, the pre-tax cost of debt is applied to the capitalized amount to ascertain the implied interest expense. This amount is then added back to income, leaving only the depreciation expense to flow through NOPAT.

As in the treatment as a capitalized lease, this adjustment brings the cost of equity into the lease treatment through the application of the cost of capital to the capitalized amount. This option will also produce a declining cost of ownership over time as the number of years to maturity declines.

This treatment, however, does require very detailed information about each operating lease as it is tracked over its life. Management will have an incentive to enter into shorter lease agreements. Consequently, the leasing function must be centralized and management must be particularly mindful of the tradeoffs between shorter leases (and smaller commitments) and the increased risk associated with renewing the lease more often.

© 2015 by Hodak Value Advisors.